I picked up A First Time for Everything by K.L. Walther on a rainy weekend, hoping for something light but real. It’s—sweet, funny, and surprisingly honest about awkward firsts.
YA coming-of-age romance stories like this keep popping up everywhere, which makes sense since so many young adults now explore dating apps and new relationships. I laughed, cringed, and maybe got a bit teary. If you want a story full of family chaos, romance, and those “first time” jitters, this one might hit the spot.
Key Takeaways
The book offers a sweet and honest look at first experiences in love and family.
Main character Mads feels real and relatable with her awkward moments and big dreams.
The writing style is light, funny, and easy to read, making the story enjoyable.
Some parts of the story move slowly and the plot can feel predictable.
Great choice for fans of coming-of-age stories who enjoy humor and heartfelt moments.
Overview
A First Time for Everything by K.L. Walther
I have to admit, I sometimes read book blurbs at midnight and instantly hit “pre-order.” That’s exactly what happened with A First Time for Everything by K.L. Walther. I saw the cover, read the summary, and just knew I needed it on my shelf. This book falls into the YA coming-of-age romance category.
If you like stories about growing up, first crushes, and family drama, you’ll probably want to check this one out.
Author and Publication
I’ll be honest, I first discovered K.L. Walther through her book The Summer of Broken Rules. That one had me hooked on her style—funny, real, and full of heart. Walther writes about teens who feel lost, hopeful, and sometimes a little messy.
She doesn’t shy away from showing the weird parts of growing up. Besides The Summer of Broken Rules, she also wrote What Happens After Midnight and If We Were Us. Each book brings a new set of characters and a fresh take on love and family.
I haven’t found much about her personal life, but her stories always feel like she’s been there. She gets the awkwardness and excitement of first times. That’s what pulled me into A First Time for Everything by K.L. Walther. I wanted to see how she’d handle another round of big feelings and new beginnings.
Plot
Main Character
Madeline, or Mads as everyone calls her, pulled me in right away. She’s the kind of girl who keeps a planner for everything. She dreams big about college and wants to play field hockey at the next level. I saw her stress about applications and try to balance her goals with her family’s expectations.
Mads isn’t perfect. She messes up, says the wrong thing, and sometimes feels invisible. That made her feel real to me. I noticed her thoughts and reactions shift as the story moved forward. She started out nervous and unsure, but I watched her grow braver with each new experience.
I loved how the author used Mads’ inner dialogue and awkward moments to show her changing. Her voice felt honest, especially when she doubted herself or tried to make sense of her feelings.
Key Events
The story kicks off when Mads’ older brother, Austin, announces his engagement. The family heads to Paris for the wedding. I could almost taste the pastries and see the Eiffel Tower through Mads’ eyes. She faces a bunch of “firsts” on this trip—her first time in Europe, her first real taste of independence, and her first big crush.
College dreams and field hockey tryouts hang over her, but Paris brings surprises. She gets lost, tries new foods, and stumbles through some hilarious disasters. Each event pushes her out of her comfort zone.
I tracked how Mads’ behavior changed after each key moment. She learned to speak up, laugh at herself, and take risks.
Relationships
Mads’ relationships drive the story. Her bond with her brother Austin feels messy but loving. They fight, tease, and support each other in their own way. The family chaos made me smile. The real twist comes with Connor, her best friend. Mads’ feelings for him sneak up on her.
She tries to hide it, but her reactions give her away. Their friendship shifts as they share secrets and face awkward moments together. I saw how these connections helped Mads figure out who she wants to be.
The way Mads interacts with her family and Connor shows her growth. Her choices and conversations reveal her changing personality.
A First Time for Everything by K.L. Walther uses these relationships and events to build a story that feels both funny and honest. I found myself rooting for Mads as she tackled each new “first.”
Themes
Coming-of-Age
I always look for that spark in a coming-of-age story—the moment when a character steps out of their comfort zone. In A First Time for Everything by K.L. Walther, I saw Mads stumble through so many “firsts.” She faces dating disasters, awkward parties, and the pressure of college dreams.
I felt her nerves when she tried something new or spoke up for herself. These moments made me remember my own teenage years, full of mistakes and small wins.
Mads learns to trust herself.
She faces her fears, even when she wants to run.
Every “first” feels big and scary, but she keeps going.
I found myself rooting for her, even when she messed up. That’s what makes a coming-of-age story stick with me.
Romance
Romance in this book feels messy and real. Mads’ crush on Connor sneaks up on her. She tries to hide it, but her feelings show in every awkward glance and nervous laugh. I liked how the story didn’t rush their relationship. It felt honest, with all the confusion and hope that comes with a first love.
The slow build between Mads and Connor made me smile.
Their friendship changes in small, believable ways.
Dating disasters add both humor and heart.
Family
Family chaos fills every chapter. Mads’ bond with her brother Austin stands out. They fight, tease, and support each other, sometimes all at once. The Paris wedding trip brings everyone together, for better or worse. I saw how family shapes Mads’ choices and gives her courage.
Sibling moments felt real and sometimes hilarious.
Parents add pressure but also give support.
Family bonds help Mads grow up.
Humor
I have to give props to K.L. Walther for making me laugh out loud. The humor in this book comes from real, awkward moments. Mads gets lost in Paris, spills secrets at the worst times, and faces dating fails that made me cringe and giggle.
Awkward situations feel honest, not forced.
Jokes break up the tension and keep things light.
I needed those laughs after some emotional scenes.
The mix of humor and emotion kept me turning pages. I never felt bored or overwhelmed.
Strengths
Writing Style
I have to give props to K.L. Walther for her writing style. She keeps things light, but she never talks down to the reader. I noticed short chapters and quick scenes that made me want to keep flipping pages. The dialogue sounds real, like something I’d overhear at a coffee shop. I never felt lost or bored.
Easy to read: Sentences stay short and clear.
Funny moments: Jokes land without feeling forced.
Relatable voice: Mads’ thoughts sound like my own at that age.
Tip: If you like books that don’t waste words, you’ll probably enjoy this one.
Characters
The characters in A First Time for Everything by K.L. Walther stand out. Mads feels like someone I could have met in high school. She’s awkward, hopeful, and sometimes a mess. Connor, her best friend, brings out her goofy side. Austin, her brother, acts like a real sibling—sometimes annoying, sometimes sweet.
Mads: Honest, flawed, and easy to root for.
Connor: Brings warmth and humor.
Family: Feels messy but real.
I liked how each character had their own quirks. No one felt flat or fake.
Emotional Impact
This book surprised me with its emotional impact. I laughed at the awkward moments. I felt a lump in my throat during the big family scenes. Some parts made me remember my own first crush and those weird, exciting days before college.
Laugh-out-loud scenes: Kept things from getting too heavy.
Tender moments: Made me pause and think.
Relatable struggles: Reminded me I’m not alone in feeling lost sometimes.
Weaknesses
Pacing
I have to admit, the pacing in “A First Time for Everything by K.L. Walther” sometimes felt off for me. I started out excited, flipping pages fast, but then I hit a few slow patches. Some scenes dragged, especially when Mads got stuck in her own head. I wanted the story to move forward, but it circled back to the same worries a few times.
Some chapters felt like filler, not much happened.
The Paris trip had moments that slowed the story down.
I found myself skimming a few pages, hoping for something big to happen.
I still enjoyed the funny and sweet moments, but I wished the story kept up the energy all the way through.
Predictability
I’ll be honest, I guessed a lot of the plot twists before they happened. The predictability didn’t ruin the book for me, but it did take away some of the excitement. I saw the romance between Mads and Connor coming from the first few chapters. The family drama followed a path I’ve seen in other YA books.
The ending felt safe, not surprising.
I could tell who would end up together.
Some “firsts” felt a little too perfect or expected.
Audience
Age Group
I kept thinking about who would love A First Time for Everything by K.L. Walther. Teens will see themselves in Mads—her awkward moments, her big dreams, and her family chaos. I also noticed that a lot of adults read YA books, too. I’m not alone in this! Here’s what I found about who’s picking up books like this:
Younger readers, especially millennials, read more books than older groups.
Avid readers (more than 4 books a month) are usually younger and more diverse.
Black, Latinx, and male millennials are some of the most engaged readers.
Latinx readers bought more books during the pandemic than anyone else.
People in the Southwest and Western U.S. love ebooks and buy them often.
So, if you’re a teen, a college student, or even an adult who loves coming-of-age stories, you’ll probably connect with this book.
Reader Interests
If you like stories about first crushes, family drama, and figuring out who you are, this book will speak to you. I always look for books that mix humor with real feelings. A First Time for Everything by K.L. Walther does that well.
Romance novels are super popular right now, with millions of copies sold every year. Most romance fans are between 18 and 44, and many started reading the genre as teens. YA novels sell over 35 million copies a year, and a lot of those readers are adults. I see why—these stories remind us of our own firsts and big changes.
I love that YA books don’t just belong to teens. Adults find comfort in these stories, too, especially when life feels uncertain.
YA Romance Comparison
I’ve read a lot of YA romance, and this one fits right in with the best of them. Books like The Summer of Broken Rules or What Happens After Midnight have the same mix of first love, family, and self-discovery.
I noticed that successful YA movies like The Fault in Our Stars and The Hunger Games also pull in huge audiences with these themes. The characters feel real, the stakes are personal, and the emotions hit home. I think A First Time for Everything by K.L. Walther stands out for its honest humor and relatable main character. It doesn’t try to shock you, but it makes you care.
If you want a story that feels like a warm hug with a few laughs and maybe a tear or two, this one is for you.
Recommendation
Should You Read A First Time for Everything by K.L. Walther?
I always get a little thrill when I add a new book to my TBR list. I know I’m not alone—about 70% of readers say their to-read shelf helps them pick their next read, and most check it at least a few times a month. I try to be picky, so I ask myself: does this book deserve a spot?
Let’s break it down:
What I Loved:
The writing feels honest and funny. I laughed at the awkward moments.
Mads is a main character I could root for. She’s real, flawed, and easy to like.
The family chaos and Paris setting add charm.
The romance is slow and believable, not forced.
Emotional scenes made me remember my own firsts.
What Didn’t Work for Me:
The pacing drags in places. Some chapters felt like filler.
I guessed most of the plot twists early. The story plays it safe.
Some “firsts” felt a little too perfect.
If you want a jaw-dropping twist, you won’t find it here.
I rate A First Time for Everything by K.L. Walther a 6.5 out of 10. It’s sweet, light, and perfect for a cozy weekend. If you like books with an average rating of 3.8 or higher, this one fits the bill.
I think it’s worth adding to your TBR if you want a story that feels like a warm hug, even if it doesn’t shock you. Just know what you’re getting: a heartfelt, funny, and sometimes predictable YA romance.
If you keep your TBR list organized and check it often, you’ll probably enjoy having this book on your shelf. I wouldn’t call it pulse-pounding, but it left me smiling. Sometimes, that’s all I need.
Sip The Unknown—Discover Stories You Never Knew You’d Love!
Dionysus Reviews Has A Book For Every Mood
Biography & Memoir
Fiction
Mystery & Detective
Nonfiction
Philosophy
Psychology
Romance
Science Fiction & Fantasy
Teens & Young Adult
Thriller & Suspense
Frequently Asked Questions
Is A First Time for Everything by K.L. Walther good for adults?
Absolutely! I read it as an adult and still found myself grinning at the awkward moments. The family chaos and honest romance work for anyone who remembers their own “firsts.”
Do I need to read K.L. Walther’s other books first?
Nope. Each story stands alone. If you liked The Summer of Broken Rules, you’ll spot her signature humor and heart here, but you won’t feel lost if this is your first Walther book.
Is the romance in this book clean?
Yes, the romance stays sweet and PG. I never felt uncomfortable. The focus stays on feelings, friendship, and those nervous first steps toward love.
Will I laugh or cry more?
Both! I laughed at the Paris mishaps and cringed at the dating fails. Some family scenes got me teary. The mix of humor and heart kept me hooked.
Would I recommend this for reluctant readers?
Definitely. The short chapters, real dialogue, and funny moments make it easy to keep going. I never felt bored or overwhelmed.
