I grabbed “Do Not Disturb” on a rainy Tuesday night after scrolling through endless thriller recommendations. Three hours later, I sat in my kitchen at 2:47 AM, black coffee gone cold, completely absorbed in Quinn Alexander’s desperate escape. My heart actually raced when she pulled into that isolated motel parking lot.
I’ve read countless psychological thrillers, but McFadden’s medical background shows immediately. Quinn’s trauma responses feel authentic, not dramatized for effect. The book follows Quinn after she commits an unnamed crime and flees toward Canada. When a snowstorm forces her into the Baxter Motel, her nightmare truly begins. I found myself questioning every character’s motives, especially motel owner Nick Baxter.
McFadden refuses to give readers easy answers about morality and survival. Quinn isn’t a clear hero or villain – she’s something much more disturbing: completely human under impossible circumstances. The book explores psychological manipulation, and the moral gray areas that define desperate people. I finished it feeling genuinely unsettled about my own capacity for survival decisions.
The Baxter Motel becomes more than setting – it’s a trap that mirrors Quinn’s psychological state. I could feel the claustrophobic dread building with each chapter, making my own living room feel suddenly too small and too quiet.
Key Takeaways
Medical authenticity elevates psychology: McFadden’s physician background creates genuinely disturbing character psychology instead of melodramatic thriller elements
Moral ambiguity refuses easy answers: No clear heroes or villains exist, forcing readers to confront uncomfortable truths about survival and ethics
Atmospheric tension through isolation: The snowbound motel setting traps both protagonist and reader in mounting dread that feels physically uncomfortable
Unreliable narration mastery: Multiple perspectives and memory gaps keep readers constantly questioning truth versus perception throughout every chapter
Genre-blending sophistication: Combines psychological thriller with survival horror while maintaining literary depth and authentic character development
Publishing Information
September 7, 2021 by Hollywood Upstairs Publishing (original self-published edition)
Note: A new edition will be published July 1, 2025 by Poisoned Pen Press/Sourcebooks
Genre: Psychological Thriller
Plot
Quinn Alexander has committed an unthinkable crime – she killed her abusive husband Derek in self-defense after he nearly strangled her to death. Fearing that no one would believe her due to her husband’s wealth and connections, Quinn decides to flee rather than face the legal system. During a snowstorm while driving toward the Canadian border, she’s forced to take refuge at the isolated and run-down Baxter Motel.
The motel is owned by Nick Baxter, who appears kind and welcoming, but the establishment harbors dark secrets. Nick’s ailing wife Rosalie constantly watches from the window of their dilapidated house across from the motel. Room 201 is never rented out due to a disturbing past incident, and Quinn discovers there’s more to the Baxter Motel than meets the eye. The story unfolds through multiple perspectives, revealing that Quinn must survive the night while confronting the motel’s sinister history and her own past.
Series Information
Standalone novel – This is not part of a series
Page Count:
325 pages (original edition)
Note: The 2025 edition will be 288 pages
Main Characters
Quinn Alexander: The protagonist who works at a bank full-time and killed her abusive husband Derek in self-defense. She suffers from residual guilt over her parents’ death when she was 14 and has endured over two years of physical and emotional abuse from Derek.
Nick Baxter: The handsome and seemingly kind owner of the Baxter Motel who offers Quinn shelter during the snowstorm. He lives with his ailing wife in the house across from the motel.
Derek: Quinn’s wealthy and well-connected abusive husband who controlled and physically harmed her throughout their marriage. His abuse escalated to attempted strangulation before Quinn killed him.
Claudia: Quinn’s older sister who tries to figure out why Quinn went on the run and attempts to keep her out of trouble. She is revealed to have bipolar disorder and harbors deep jealousy and resentment toward Quinn.
Greta: An elderly psychic who lives full-time at the Baxter Motel and provides Quinn with cryptic warnings and insights.
Rosalie: Nick’s ailing wife who constantly watches the motel from her window in the house across the way, creating an unsettling atmosphere.
Plot Synopsis and Psychological Setup
Quinn’s opening panic grabbed me immediately. I felt her desperation as she fled after committing what she calls an “unthinkable crime.” McFadden drops readers into Quinn’s frantic mindset without explanation – we experience her terror before understanding its source. This technique worked perfectly on me. I kept reading to discover what Quinn had done.
The psychological setup feels real because McFadden doesn’t reveal Quinn’s crime right away. Instead, I experienced her guilt and paranoia firsthand. Quinn’s hypervigilance made every gas station stop feel dangerous. Her constant checking of rearview mirrors had me looking over my own shoulder while reading.
Quinn Alexander’s Flight and Moral Ambiguity
Quinn embodies the book’s central theme perfectly – she’s simultaneously victim and perpetrator. I found myself rooting for her escape while dreading what she might have actually done. McFadden crafts Quinn with enough complexity that my sympathies kept shifting throughout the story.
The flight sequences include realistic details about evading law enforcement. Quinn’s paranoia about every police car, her careful cash-only purchases, her avoidance of highway cameras – these details convinced me McFadden researched actual fugitive behavior. Quinn’s internal monologue reveals someone teetering on complete psychological breakdown.
Baxter Motel as the Catalyst for Suspense
When the snowstorm traps Quinn at the Baxter Motel, I immediately felt something wrong. Nick Baxter’s excessive helpfulness triggered all my thriller-reader instincts. McFadden uses the setting brilliantly – the isolated location amplifies Quinn’s vulnerability while introducing new threats she can’t escape.
The motel feels alive with menace. Every creaking floorboard made me tense. The flickering lights and broken heating system add atmospheric dread without relying on obvious horror tropes. I appreciated how McFadden builds fear through subtle wrongness rather than jump scares.
McFadden’s Hitchcockian Atmosphere and Setting
McFadden channels classic suspense masters, particularly Hitchcock’s ability to make ordinary situations terrifying. The snowstorm isn’t just weather – it becomes Quinn’s prison, trapping her with potentially dangerous strangers. I felt genuinely claustrophobic reading the storm descriptions.
The psychological atmosphere builds through small details that accumulate into major dread. Nick’s overly accommodating behavior feels wrong, but I couldn’t pinpoint exactly why until much later. This uncertainty creates sustained tension that kept me reading past my usual bedtime.
Isolation and Claustrophobia in a Snowstorm
The snowstorm serves multiple narrative purposes beyond simple plot device. It reflects Quinn’s chaotic internal state – blinding, dangerous, potentially deadly. The physical isolation mirrors her psychological isolation as someone who can’t trust anyone with her secrets.
McFadden excels at describing claustrophobic atmosphere. The heating system’s failures, snow blocking windows, gradual loss of cell service – each detail tightened the trap around Quinn and me as reader. I felt her growing panic as escape options disappeared.
Symbolism of Entrapment and Psychological Decay
The motel represents Quinn’s psychological prison more than physical confinement. Her guilt transforms every room into a potential trap. McFadden uses the deteriorating building to mirror Quinn’s mental state – peeling wallpaper reflects her psychological decay.
The symbolism never feels heavy-handed because McFadden weaves it naturally into descriptions. The motel’s “Do Not Disturb” signs become darkly ironic given how disturbed everyone’s mental state becomes. This attention to symbolic detail elevates the book above standard thriller territory.
Character Development and Psychological Complexity
McFadden’s greatest strength lies in creating psychologically complex characters who defy easy categorization. Quinn isn’t a typical thriller protagonist – she’s morally compromised, unreliable, potentially dangerous. Yet McFadden makes her sympathetic enough that I remained invested in her survival throughout.
Nick Baxter could easily have been one-dimensional villain material. Instead, McFadden gives him layers that kept his motivations genuinely unclear until the climax. This character depth distinguishes the book from thrillers that rely solely on plot twists for impact.
Quinn’s Internal Conflict and Survival Psychology
Quinn’s psychological journey forms the book’s emotional core. Her conflict between self-preservation and moral conscience creates authentic tension beyond simple plot mechanics. McFadden’s medical knowledge shows in realistic trauma response portrayals.
I found Quinn’s mental deterioration believable because McFadden shows rather than tells. Her increasing paranoia, memory gaps, distorted perceptions – these feel like genuine stress responses rather than convenient plot devices. The psychology feels clinical without being dry or overly technical.
Nick Baxter’s Dual Nature and Narrative Deception
Nick represents McFadden’s most successful character creation. His apparent kindness masks something darker, but McFadden keeps his true nature ambiguous for most of the story. This uncertainty made every Quinn-Nick interaction feel potentially explosive.
The gradual revelation of Nick’s background provides some of the book’s most chilling moments. McFadden avoids making him purely evil, instead creating a character whose actions stem from understandable but twisted logic. This complexity makes him far more frightening than typical thriller antagonists.
Narrative Structure and Perspective Shifts
McFadden employs sophisticated narrative structure that enhances rather than complicates the story. Perspective shifts between characters provide crucial information while maintaining suspense. Each viewpoint reveals new mystery layers without feeling gimmicky.
The temporal structure works particularly well, with flashbacks and present action woven seamlessly together. I never felt confused about timeline or perspective, which speaks to McFadden’s skill in managing complex narrative elements without showing off.
Unreliable Narrators and Temporal Rollbacks
The book’s unreliable narrators create genuine uncertainty about events and motivations. Quinn’s trauma-affected memory and Nick’s potential deception mean I couldn’t trust any single perspective completely. This narrative technique maintains suspense throughout.
McFadden handles temporal rollbacks skillfully, revealing information at precisely the right moments to maintain tension while providing necessary context. The flashbacks feel organic rather than imposed, each adding crucial psychological puzzle pieces without disrupting narrative flow.
Impact on Suspense and Reader Immersion
The narrative techniques directly enhance reader engagement by creating active participation in solving the mystery. I constantly reevaluated previous scenes based on new information, which kept me deeply invested in the story’s outcome.
Immersion remains high because McFadden balances complexity with clarity. Despite multiple perspectives and timeline shifts, the story never becomes confusing or pretentious. The techniques serve thriller elements rather than overwhelming them with literary showing off.
Thematic Depth and Genre Relevance
Beyond surface thrills, “Do Not Disturb” explores serious themes about domestic trauma, survival psychology, and moral ambiguity. McFadden treats these subjects with appropriate gravity while maintaining entertainment value. The thematic depth elevates it above typical genre fiction.
The book’s exploration of how extreme circumstances reveal character provides genuine insight into human nature. Quinn and Nick’s actions under pressure feel psychologically authentic rather than contrived for plot convenience. This thematic sophistication distinguishes McFadden’s work in the crowded thriller market.
Exploration of Domestic Abuse and Trauma
McFadden handles domestic abuse themes with sensitivity and psychological accuracy. The trauma’s impact on Quinn’s behavior and decision-making feels realistic rather than exploitative. The book avoids graphic descriptions while conveying lasting psychological damage such experiences create.
The treatment of trauma adds emotional weight to thriller elements. Quinn’s actions stem from understandable psychological responses rather than plot convenience, which makes her character more compelling and the story more emotionally resonant with real-world experiences.
Comparison with Contemporary Psychological Thrillers
“Do Not Disturb” stands out in contemporary psychological thriller fiction through authentic character psychology and moral complexity. Many thrillers rely on shocking plot twists, but McFadden builds suspense through character development and psychological authenticity.
Compared to authors like Gillian Flynn or Tana French, McFadden brings unique medical knowledge to psychological portrayals. Her characters’ mental states feel clinically accurate while remaining accessible to general readers. This combination sets her work apart in the genre.
Reading Experience and Accessibility
The book maintains excellent pacing throughout its 325 pages, with tension building steadily without becoming exhausting. I read it in two sittings because the suspense made it genuinely difficult to put down. McFadden balances psychological complexity with page-turning readability perfectly.
The writing style remains accessible without dumbing down psychological elements. Medical and psychological terms are explained naturally within context, making the book appropriate for readers without specialized knowledge while satisfying those seeking depth.
| Reading Aspect | Rating | My Experience |
|---|---|---|
| Pacing | 8/10 | Kept me reading past 2 AM twice |
| Character Development | 7/10 | Quinn felt completely real, secondary characters less so |
| Psychological Authenticity | 9/10 | McFadden’s medical background shows clearly |
| Plot Complexity | 7/10 | Sophisticated without being confusing |
| Emotional Impact | 8/10 | Left me questioning my own moral boundaries |
The book works well in both print and audiobook formats. I tried both – the print version lets you flip back to catch details you missed, while the audio narrators Holly Adams and Daniel Thomas May bring the characters to life effectively.
Comparative Analysis with Similar Works
“Do Not Disturb” fits within psychological thriller subgenre but distinguishes itself through McFadden’s medical expertise and focus on authentic trauma responses. Compared to Ruth Ware’s isolated setting thrillers, McFadden’s medical knowledge adds clinical authenticity to character psychology.
The book shares DNA with Stephen King’s psychological horror but maintains tighter focus on character psychology rather than supernatural elements. McFadden’s approach feels more grounded in reality while delivering comparable tension and atmosphere.
| Similar Books | What They Share | How McFadden Differs |
|---|---|---|
| The Woman in the Window | Unreliable narrator mastery | Medical authenticity in psychology |
| Behind Closed Doors | Domestic abuse themes | Survival psychology focus |
| The Guest List | Multiple perspectives | Clinical accuracy in trauma portrayal |
| Sharp Objects | Psychological complexity | More accessible writing style |
Against contemporary bestsellers like “The Guest List” or “The Silent Patient”, McFadden’s work holds up well, offering comparable psychological depth with superior medical authenticity in character development.
Pros
Psychological Authenticity: McFadden’s medical background creates genuinely believable character psychology. Quinn’s trauma responses feel clinically accurate rather than melodramatic, adding credibility that most thrillers lack.
Atmospheric Excellence: The snowbound motel setting becomes a character itself. I felt genuinely claustrophobic reading Quinn’s entrapment. The isolation mirrors the characters’ psychological states perfectly.
Moral Complexity: The book avoids simple good-versus-evil dynamics. Characters have understandable but questionable motivations. This ambiguity made me think long after finishing the book.
Pacing Mastery: Tension builds steadily without becoming exhausting. I found myself saying “just one more chapter” repeatedly. The structure maintains engagement from beginning to end.
Character Development: Quinn and Nick are complex characters who defy easy categorization. Their psychological depth elevates the book above simple plot-driven thrillers significantly.
Cons
Predictable Elements: Some plot developments become obvious before their revelation, particularly regarding Nick’s true nature. I saw certain twists coming chapters ahead.
Secondary Character Development: Characters beyond Quinn and Nick feel underdeveloped, serving primarily as plot devices rather than fully realized individuals with their own believable motivations.
Resolution Pacing: The climax feels somewhat rushed compared to the careful buildup throughout the rest of the book. Some plot threads needed more thorough exploration.
Limited Setting Scope: The confined motel location works effectively but limits opportunities for broader character development and plot complexity that might strengthen the overall story.
Genre Conventions: Despite its strengths, the book relies on familiar thriller tropes and doesn’t break significant new ground in terms of genre innovation or literary experimentation.
Final Verdict
“Do Not Disturb” succeeds as sophisticated psychological thriller fiction that respects both entertainment value and psychological authenticity. McFadden’s medical background adds genuine credibility to character psychology, setting her work apart in a crowded genre market.
The moral ambiguity and complex character psychology make this more than simple escapist fiction. Quinn and Nick’s psychological complexity provided material for reflection long after I finished reading. The themes of survival, trauma, and moral compromise resonate beyond the thriller framework.
I recommend “Do Not Disturb” for readers who appreciate psychological complexity in their thriller fiction. Those seeking purely plot-driven action might find the character focus less appealing, but readers who enjoy authors like Tana French or Gillian Flynn will likely appreciate McFadden’s approach.
The book works particularly well for readers interested in the intersection of psychology and thriller fiction. McFadden’s medical expertise adds authenticity that strengthens rather than overwhelms the entertainment value, creating a satisfying balance between literary merit and genre conventions.
After reading thousands of psychological thrillers, I can confidently say “Do Not Disturb” represents solid genre fiction that exceeds expectations through character depth and psychological authenticity. It left me questioning the nature of survival instincts and moral compromise days after reading the final page.
Dionysus Reviews Rating: 7/10
Sip The Unknown—Discover Stories You Never Knew You’d Love!
Dionysus Reviews Has A Book For Every Mood
Biography & Memoir
Fiction
Mystery & Detective
Nonfiction
Philosophy
Psychology
Romance
Science Fiction & Fantasy
Teens & Young Adult
Thriller & Suspense
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the significance of Room 201 at the Baxter Motel?
Room 201 is never rented out because someone was murdered in that room, which is right next to where Quinn stays. The room has a disturbing past that connects to the motel’s dark history, and there are mysterious red leaks coming from the room that add to the horror atmosphere.
How does Claudia’s bipolar disorder affect the story’s major plot twists?
Claudia’s bipolar disorder is mentioned as creating “two different personalities/two different narratives,” which becomes crucial to understanding the book’s major revelation. Her condition contributes to the dramatic personality shifts that readers notice, where she transforms from appearing empathetic and concerned to being “cold-hearted and full of revenge”.
Why doesn’t Quinn call the police or claim self-defense after killing Derek?
Quinn fears that no one would believe her story of self-defense because Derek is wealthy, well-regarded, and well-connected in their community. Despite having physical evidence of abuse (bruising on her neck from his attempted strangulation), she believes his social status and financial resources would destroy her life if she stayed to face the legal system.
What role does the fortune teller Greta play in Quinn’s stay at the motel?
Greta is a long-term resident at the Baxter Motel who serves as a psychic advisor and provides Quinn with warnings about the dangers she faces. She offers cryptic insights that help Quinn navigate the threatening situation at the motel and represents a connection to the supernatural elements woven throughout the thriller.
How does the revelation about the true antagonist change the reader’s understanding of the entire story?
The book’s major twist reveals that appearances are deceiving, with characters showing dramatic personality changes that only make sense when viewed through the lens of the final revelation. The shift in understanding who the real threat is creates a situation where previous chapters and character motivations need to be reinterpreted, leading some readers to feel that earlier character development doesn’t align with the ultimate truth.
