I have to say, Finders Keepers by Sarah Adler made me smile a lot at midnight. If you like friends-to-lovers stories with a fun treasure hunt, this book gives you that. Sarah Adler is getting more popular for a reason—her romantic comedies always feel new and really fun.
Key Takeaways
Finders Keepers gives a new and fun friends-to-lovers romance.
It has a smart treasure hunt that keeps readers interested.
The book stands out with funny talk, real feelings, and characters who seem real and easy to like.
Readers who like stories with heart, jokes, second chances, and a happy ending will think this book is fun and easy to remember.
Why Read Finders Keepers by Sarah Adler?
Overall Recommendation
I’ll be honest, I started Finders Keepers by Sarah Adler thinking I’d read a chapter or two before bed. Next thing I knew, I was still flipping pages at 2 a.m., grinning like a fool. This book has that rare spark that makes you want to keep reading, even when you know you should sleep.
The story feels fresh, the banter is sharp, and the characters are so easy to root for. I have to give props to Sarah Adler for making me care about these two friends so quickly. By chapter two, I felt like I knew them.
I saw a review from Sara D’Onofrio who gave this book a perfect 5-star rating. She finished it in just 24 hours and said she felt connected to the characters almost instantly. She loved the witty, heartwarming banter and the way the story used letters to pull her in.
She even said the ending felt perfect and satisfying, which is rare for me to hear from other romance readers. That kind of praise makes me trust my own reaction even more.
If you want a book that can make you laugh, swoon, and maybe even tear up a little, this one delivers. The third act breakup actually made sense (which is not always the case in romance), and the ending left me with a happy sigh.
Who Will Love This Book
Not every romance hits the sweet spot for everyone, but I think this one comes close. Here’s who I think will love Finders Keepers by Sarah Adler:
Fans of friends-to-lovers stories who want more than just recycled tropes.
Readers who enjoy a good treasure hunt mixed with real emotional stakes.
Anyone who likes witty banter and clever, heartfelt dialogue.
People who want a romance that feels both fun and meaningful.
Those who appreciate a story about second chances and reconnecting with someone from your past.
If you’ve ever stayed up way too late because you couldn’t put a book down, you’ll get why I recommend this one. The writing feels smooth and easy to read, but the emotions sneak up on you. I laughed, I swooned, and I even got a little misty-eyed at one point. That’s the kind of reading experience I look for.
Plot and Premise
Treasure Hunt Story
I have to admit, the treasure hunt in this book hooked me right away. I love when a story gives me a reason to keep guessing. The hunt isn’t just about finding something shiny. It’s about memories, regrets, and the hope of fixing old mistakes. The clues felt clever but not too tricky. I never felt lost or bored.
The hunt takes the characters to quirky places that made me laugh.
Each clue reveals more about their past and what they mean to each other.
The adventure side of the story kept my energy up, even when my eyes wanted to close.
Note: If you like stories where the journey matters as much as the prize, this one will make you happy.
Friends-to-Lovers Trope
I know some people roll their eyes at friends-to-lovers, but this book does it right. The main duo starts as estranged best friends. Their history feels real, not forced. I could feel the awkwardness, the longing, and the slow return of trust.
The romance grows with every shared secret and inside joke.
I rooted for them because their connection felt honest.
The tension between wanting to stay friends and risking it all for love had me turning pages fast.
This story reminded me why I keep coming back to this trope. It’s not just about falling in love. It’s about finding your way back to someone who knows you best.
Characters
Main Duo
I have to admit, the main duo in this book pulled me in right away. Their chemistry felt real from the start. I could almost hear their laughter and feel the awkward silences between them. These two are estranged best friends, and I loved watching them try to figure each other out again.
Both characters have flaws, but that made them feel human.
I saw their pain and hope in every conversation.
Their inside jokes and shared memories made me smile.
I found myself rooting for them, even when they made mistakes. The author didn’t make them perfect, and that’s what made their story work for me.
Relationship Growth
Watching their relationship change felt like a slow burn in the best way. I could see the trust building with every page. They started out guarded, but little by little, they let their walls down.
Each clue in the treasure hunt brought them closer.
I noticed small moments—like a lingering look or a shared laugh—that showed their feelings growing.
The theme of second chances stood out. Both characters had to face their past and decide if they wanted to move forward.
Note: I felt their growth, not just as a couple, but as individuals. They learned to forgive, to be honest, and to take risks. That made their happy ending feel earned.
I finished this part of Finders Keepers by Sarah Adler feeling hopeful. The emotional depth and personal growth made the romance feel real.
Writing Style
Humor and Banter
I laughed out loud more than once while reading Finders Keepers by Sarah Adler. The humor feels sharp and never forced. The characters toss jokes back and forth like old friends. I found myself grinning at their inside jokes and playful teasing. The banter made the story feel alive.
Quick, witty exchanges kept me turning pages.
The jokes never felt mean or awkward.
Even the serious moments had a light touch that made me smile.
If you love books that make you laugh and swoon at the same time, this one hits the mark.
Narrative Devices
Sarah Adler uses some clever tricks to pull readers in. She mixes present-day scenes with letters and memories. I liked how these pieces fit together, giving me a deeper look at the characters’ past. The treasure hunt structure also kept the story moving.
Letters reveal secrets and old feelings.
Flashbacks add layers to the friendship.
The clues in the hunt push the plot forward.
I never felt lost or confused. The story flows smoothly, even with the jumps in time.
Finders Keepers by Sarah Adler: Voice
The voice in Finders Keepers by Sarah Adler feels warm and real. I could hear the characters in my head. The writing pulled me in so much that I stayed up late, even though my baby wakes up once or twice a night.
That’s not something I do for every book. The prose made me gasp with delight more than once. I have to give props to Adler for making the story so immersive and emotionally rich.
The author’s style made me care about every moment, big or small.
Strengths
I have to admit, this book surprised me in the best way. I found myself reading way past my bedtime, which almost never happens these days. Here’s what stood out for me:
Chemistry that feels real: The main duo’s connection jumps off the page. Their inside jokes and awkward moments made me smile. I could feel their history in every scene.
Sharp, funny dialogue: The banter had me laughing out loud. It never felt forced or cheesy. I love when a book makes me grin at the page.
Treasure hunt with heart: The clues and adventures kept me guessing. Each step brought out more emotion and backstory. I cared about the journey, not just the prize.
Emotional payoff: The story gave me all the feels. I rooted for these two, even when they messed up. The ending left me with a happy sigh.
Easy to read: The writing flows. I never felt lost or bored. The mix of letters, flashbacks, and present-day scenes kept things fresh.
If you want a romance that feels both fun and meaningful, this one delivers. I have to give props to the author for making me care so much about these characters.
I finished the last page feeling lighter and a little more hopeful. That’s rare for me. This book gave me exactly what I needed—a story that made me laugh, swoon, and maybe tear up a bit.
Weaknesses
I have to be honest, even books that make me smile at midnight have a few bumps. I found myself wishing for just a bit more in some places. Here’s what stood out to me:
Pacing felt uneven: The treasure hunt had me hooked, but a few chapters dragged. I caught myself skimming when the story slowed down. Sometimes, the clues took a back seat to the characters’ inner thoughts. I wanted the adventure to keep moving.
Side characters faded: I liked the main duo, but the supporting cast didn’t stick with me. I wanted more from their friends and family. They popped in and out, but I never felt connected to them.
Predictable moments: The friends-to-lovers path felt familiar. I guessed a few twists before they happened. The story still made me care, but I hoped for a surprise or two.
Emotional whiplash: Some scenes jumped from funny to serious so fast, I needed a second to catch up. I love a good mix of laughs and feels, but the shifts sometimes felt jarring.
Letters and flashbacks: I enjoyed the letters, but a few slowed the pace. I wanted to get back to the present-day action.
To be fair, none of these issues ruined my fun. I still finished with a happy sigh. If you want a light, heartfelt read, these bumps might not bother you at all.
Personal Impressions
Memorable Moments
I have to admit, some scenes in this book stuck with me long after I finished. I found myself grinning at the memory of Nina and Quentin talking through their bedroom windows. Quentin’s bad French accent as he pretended to be the Moon? That made me laugh out loud. It felt silly and sweet at the same time.
The window conversations between Nina and Quentin brought out both humor and vulnerability.
Their dance to “Never Had a Dream Come True” by SClub7 during a 90s and 00s theme night hit me with a wave of nostalgia. I could almost hear the song in my head.
The treasure hunt itself added a playful energy. Each clue made me want to keep reading, just to see what would happen next.
The banter between Nina and Quentin felt so real. I caught myself wishing I could join their inside jokes.
I loved how the story balanced funny moments with real emotion. The rekindling of their friendship and romance felt honest and a little bit quirky. I finished the book feeling lighter, like I’d just spent time with old friends.
Comparison to Other Romances
I read a lot of contemporary romance, but this one stands out for a few reasons:
The treasure hunt plot gave the story a fresh twist. Most romances stick to the usual meet-cute or forced proximity, but this adventure kept things moving.
The humor felt natural. I didn’t roll my eyes once at the jokes, which is rare for me.
The emotional depth surprised me. I expected laughs, but I didn’t expect to get misty-eyed over a childhood friendship turning into something more.
If you like books with charm, wit, and a little nostalgia, this one delivers. I’d put it on the same shelf as books by Emily Henry or Christina Lauren, but it has its own quirky heart. I have to give props to the author for making me care so much about these characters in such a short time.
If you want a romance that feels both fun and meaningful, I’d say give Finders Keepers by Sarah Adler a shot.
The witty banter, treasure hunt, and real emotional growth made me smile.
Perfect for anyone who loves friends-to-lovers stories with heart.
Final verdict: worth staying up late for.
Sip The Unknown—Discover Stories You Never Knew You’d Love!
Dionysus Reviews Has A Book For Every Mood
Biography & Memoir
Fiction
Mystery & Detective
Nonfiction
Philosophy
Psychology
Romance
Science Fiction & Fantasy
Teens & Young Adult
Thriller & Suspense
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Finders Keepers by Sarah Adler a standalone book?
Yes, it stands alone. You don’t need to read anything else first. The story wraps up with no cliffhangers.
Does the book have any steamy scenes?
No, the romance stays sweet and closed-door. I never felt awkward reading it in public or with family around.
Will I like this if I’m not a big romance reader?
If you enjoy witty banter, quirky adventures, and stories about second chances, you might like it. The treasure hunt adds a fun twist, even for non-romance fans.
