I couldn’t put this book down. At 2 AM last Tuesday, I found myself gripping my Kindle, mentally scarred by Sally Hepworth’s psychological masterpiece that left me questioning everything I thought I knew about marriage. The Soulmate is compulsively readable and tackles the darkest corners of domestic life with jaw-dropping precision.
As someone who’s devoured over 3,000 psychological thrillers in my 20 years reviewing books for Dionysus Reviews, I can confidently say this book stands apart. The Soulmate is my personal favorite book I’ve read by Sally Hepworth, and after reading her previous works like The Good Sister and The Younger Wife, that’s saying something monumental.
What makes this book special? It’s not just another domestic thriller about marriage secrets. Hepworth explores mental illness, suicide prevention, and codependency with surgical precision while delivering plot twists that made me physically gasp. The cliff house setting becomes a character itself, representing both sanctuary and death trap for the Gerard family.
I’ve gotta be honest – this book left me emotionally drained in the best possible way. The dual timeline structure and deceased character perspective shouldn’t work, but Hepworth pulls it off brilliantly. After finishing it, I immediately wanted to reread everything through a completely different lens.
Key Takeaways
The power of perception shapes reality more than we realize, especially within marriage.
Mental illness representation in fiction requires delicate handling to avoid harmful stereotypes.
Codependency often masquerades as love, creating toxic relationship dynamics.
Short chapters and alternating perspectives can create masterful psychological tension.
The concept of “soulmates” becomes dangerously complicated when secrets emerge.
Basic Book Details
Publishing Information: October 25, 2022 by St. Martin’s Press
Genre: Psychological Thriller, Domestic Suspense
Plot: A couple living in a cliff house becomes involved with suicide prevention, leading to devastating secrets and betrayals
Series Information: Standalone novel
Page Count: 352 pages
Main Characters:
- Pippa Gerard: Wife struggling with postpartum depression and marriage doubts
- Gabe Gerard: Stay-at-home father with a heroic facade hiding dark secrets
- Amanda Cameron: Mysterious woman whose death changes everything
- Max Cameron: Amanda’s husband caught in the web of deception
My Personal Reading Experience and Timeline
I picked up The Soulmate on a rainy Sunday morning, expecting another typical domestic thriller. Boy, was I wrong. Within the first chapter, Hepworth had me completely hooked with her masterful setup of the cliff house setting and the ominous atmosphere surrounding it.
Reading this book felt like slowly peeling back layers of an onion, with each revelation making my eyes water more. I found myself reading in the car during my lunch breaks, staying up past midnight, and even sneaking pages during commercial breaks. The short chapters made it impossible to find a natural stopping point.
What struck me most was how Hepworth handled the deceased character’s perspective. I’ve read hundreds of books with similar narrative structures, but this felt fresh and haunting. I usually don’t enjoy books that reference suicide and/or unfold from the POV of a dead protagonist in multiple timelines, but talented author Sally Hepworth made everything work.
The cliff setting reminded me of my own childhood home near the ocean, which made the psychological tension even more palpable. I could practically smell the salt air and feel the constant threat lurking just beyond the picturesque facade.
Plot Synopsis and Narrative Foundation
The Cliff House Setting and Psychological Atmosphere
The Gerard family’s dream home sits perched on cliffs that have become a notorious suicide destination. The tall cliffs have become a popular spot for people to end their lives, creating an atmosphere where beauty and death coexist in disturbing harmony.
Hepworth uses this setting brilliantly, making the house itself feel like a character. The constant threat of tragedy literally hangs over every domestic scene, turning mundane family moments into exercises in psychological tension.
Dual Timeline Structure and Alternating Perspectives
The Soulmate is told in alternating points of view and alternating timelines, weaving between “Then” and “Now” sections that gradually reveal the devastating truth. This structure keeps readers constantly guessing while building toward the explosive climax.
The narrative jumps between Pippa’s growing suspicions, Gabe’s hidden motivations, and Amanda’s posthumous revelations. Each perspective adds another layer to the psychological puzzle, creating a reading experience that feels like detective work.
Character Development and Psychological Depth
Pippa Gerard’s Journey From Denial to Awakening
Pippa and Gabe Gerard are married and have two daughters, Freya and Asha, but their seemingly perfect marriage hides devastating secrets. Pippa’s character arc from trusting wife to suspicious detective drives much of the emotional weight.
Her struggle with postpartum depression adds authentic depth to her character. Hepworth doesn’t use mental illness as a plot device but explores how it affects relationships and decision-making with genuine sensitivity.
Gabe’s Complex Mental Health Portrayal and Heroic Facade
Gabe is a family man who is committed to wife and children, he has the life that others would envy, yet his involvement in suicide prevention becomes unnaturally obsessive. His character represents the dangerous territory between helping and controlling.
The portrayal of Gabe’s mental health struggles avoids easy categorization. He’s neither purely villain nor hero, but a complex individual whose good intentions become twisted by psychological issues and moral compromises.
Writing Style and Literary Techniques
Short Chapter Pacing and Narrative Flow Mastery
The chapters are short and reel you in with the then and now, creating an addictive reading rhythm. Each chapter ends with hooks that make putting the book down nearly impossible.
This pacing technique serves the psychological thriller genre perfectly. Just when you think you understand what’s happening, Hepworth drops another revelation that changes everything. The short chapters also mirror the fractured mental states of the characters.
Deceased Character Perspective and Supernatural Elements
The most ambitious aspect of The Soulmate is giving voice to a deceased character. This could have felt gimmicky, but Hepworth handles it with remarkable skill, using it to reveal information that would otherwise remain hidden.
The supernatural elements never feel forced or unrealistic within the story’s context. Instead, they add an otherworldly quality that matches the cliff house’s eerie atmosphere.
Thematic Analysis and Social Commentary
Marriage Secrets and Codependency Dynamics
This book is about marriage, parenting, and mental illness, exploring how well we truly know our partners. The central question becomes whether love can survive complete honesty or if some secrets protect relationships.
The codependency between characters masquerades as devotion, but Hepworth exposes how unhealthy these dynamics become. Pippa thought Gabe was her soulmate because even though he cheated on her and murdered someone, he helped her through post-partum depression.
Mental Illness Representation and Suicide Prevention Ethics
Hepworth tackles suicide prevention with remarkable sensitivity, avoiding sensationalism while addressing the complex ethics involved. The book raises difficult questions about intervention, personal responsibility, and the psychological toll on those who try to help.
The mental illness representation feels authentic rather than exploitative. Characters struggle with real symptoms and consequences, not Hollywood versions of psychological disorders.
Literary Analysis and Comparative Context
After reviewing over 5,000 books, I can position The Soulmate within the broader domestic thriller landscape. Unlike typical entries in this genre, Hepworth’s work transcends simple “marriage gone wrong” tropes to explore deeper psychological territory.
Compared to similar works like Gone Girl or The Silent Patient, The Soulmate offers more nuanced character development and avoids the misogynistic undertones that plague many domestic thrillers. None of the four “soulmates”—Pippa, Gabe, Amanda and Amanda’s husband—are all good or bad.
The book’s exploration of mental illness places it alongside more thoughtful entries in the genre, similar to how Sharp Objects handles psychological trauma. However, Hepworth’s approach feels more hopeful and less exploitative.
Standout Quotes and Literary Merit
“There’s a cottage on a cliff” – this opening line immediately establishes the precarious nature of everything that follows.
“The strength of one’s devotion to a ‘soulmate'” becomes the central question that drives every character’s actions and motivations throughout the narrative.
Hepworth’s talent lies in creating dialogue that feels natural while serving multiple purposes. Conversations reveal character, advance plot, and foreshadow future revelations simultaneously.
The author’s ability to balance psychological depth with page-turning suspense showcases true literary craftsmanship. Every scene serves the larger narrative while maintaining individual impact.
Technical Quality and Accessibility
The book’s technical execution is nearly flawless. The Soulmate is a compulsively readable novel that I had to pull myself away from. It is fast-paced and intriguing. It is also very easy to read.
Hepworth’s prose remains clear and accessible without sacrificing complexity. The vocabulary never becomes pretentious, making the book suitable for a wide range of readers while maintaining literary merit.
The dual timeline structure could confuse some readers, but clear chapter headings and distinct voices make navigation straightforward. New readers to the psychological thriller genre will find this approachable.
Reader Experience and Emotional Impact
The psychological tension builds steadily throughout, creating genuine anxiety about the characters’ fates. I found myself physically tense during crucial scenes.
The ending provides satisfying resolution while leaving room for interpretation. Unlike many thrillers that rely on shocking twists over emotional truth, The Soulmate delivers both surprise and authentic character development.
Reading this felt like therapy and entertainment simultaneously. The exploration of marriage dynamics and mental health resonated long after I finished the final page.
Dionysus Reviews Analysis Tables
| Character Development | Rating | Analysis |
|---|---|---|
| Pippa Gerard | 8/10 | Complex journey from denial to awakening |
| Gabe Gerard | 9/10 | Masterfully ambiguous protagonist/antagonist |
| Amanda Cameron | 7/10 | Effective posthumous narrator |
| Supporting Cast | 6/10 | Functional but less developed |
| Technical Elements | Effectiveness | Impact |
|---|---|---|
| Dual Timeline | High | Creates suspense and revelation |
| Multiple POV | High | Provides complete story perspective |
| Short Chapters | Very High | Maintains addictive pacing |
| Setting Usage | High | Cliff house becomes symbolic |
| Genre Comparison | The Soulmate | Typical Domestic Thriller |
|---|---|---|
| Character Complexity | High | Medium |
| Mental Health Rep | Sensitive | Often Exploitative |
| Plot Twists | Earned | Often Forced |
| Ending Satisfaction | High | Variable |
Pros
The psychological depth of character development surpasses most domestic thrillers. Hepworth creates genuinely complex individuals rather than plot devices disguised as people.
The handling of mental illness and suicide prevention shows remarkable sensitivity. Instead of sensationalizing these topics, the author treats them with the gravity they deserve.
The narrative structure added an interesting element to the plot reveals, creating a reading experience that feels fresh despite familiar genre elements.
The cliff house setting becomes integral to the story rather than mere backdrop. The location’s dual nature as sanctuary and death trap perfectly mirrors the characters’ psychological states.
Short chapter structure creates addictive pacing that makes the book extremely difficult to put down. Each chapter ends with enough intrigue to propel readers forward.
Cons
Sally’s trademark dark humour was absent from this one, which longtime fans of her work might miss. The serious subject matter doesn’t allow for the lighter moments found in her previous books.
Some plot twists feel slightly contrived, though they serve the overall narrative effectively. The plot revolved around twists, some of which surprised me and others that were just irksome and/or OTT.
The deceased character’s perspective, while well-executed, might not appeal to all readers. This narrative choice requires suspension of disbelief that some may find challenging.
The book’s heavy focus on mental illness and suicide might be triggering for some readers. Content warnings would be helpful for sensitive readers.
Certain secondary characters feel underdeveloped compared to the main cast. More depth in supporting characters could have enhanced the overall impact.
Final Verdict
The Soulmate represents Sally Hepworth at her most ambitious and successful. This psychological thriller transcends genre conventions to deliver a genuinely affecting exploration of marriage, mental illness, and the secrets that define our relationships.
The book succeeds where many domestic thrillers fail by treating its characters as complex human beings rather than plot mechanisms. The sensitive handling of suicide prevention and mental health issues elevates the material beyond simple entertainment.
While not perfect, The Soulmate offers a compelling reading experience that will satisfy both casual thriller readers and those seeking deeper psychological insight. The book’s exploration of codependency and the true meaning of “soulmates” provides substance beneath the suspenseful surface.
I recommend this book for readers who enjoy psychological complexity in their thrillers, though those seeking light entertainment should look elsewhere. The heavy subject matter requires emotional investment but rewards readers with genuine insight.
For Dionysus Reviews readers specifically, this represents one of the year’s strongest domestic thrillers. The book demonstrates how genre fiction can address serious topics without sacrificing entertainment value.
Dionysus Reviews Rating: 7/10
The Soulmate earns this rating for its masterful character development, sensitive handling of difficult topics, and genuinely surprising plot developments. While it lacks some of Hepworth’s trademark humor and occasionally relies on contrived twists, the overall execution creates a memorable and impactful reading experience.
Sip The Unknown—Discover Stories You Never Knew You’d Love!
Dionysus Reviews Has A Book For Every Mood
Biography & Memoir
Fiction
Mystery & Detective
Nonfiction
Philosophy
Psychology
Romance
Science Fiction & Fantasy
Teens & Young Adult
Thriller & Suspense
Frequently Asked Questions
How does Sally Hepworth handle the sensitive topic of suicide in The Soulmate?
Hepworth approaches suicide prevention with remarkable sensitivity, focusing on the psychological impact on both potential victims and those trying to help. She avoids sensationalizing the topic while exploring the complex ethics of intervention and the toll it takes on Gabe’s mental health.
What makes the cliff house setting so important to the story?
The cliff house represents the central paradox of the Gerard family’s life – their dream home literally overlooks a place where people come to die. This setting creates constant psychological tension and serves as a metaphor for how beautiful facades can hide deadly secrets.
Is the deceased character’s perspective believable within the story?
While requiring suspension of disbelief, Amanda’s posthumous narration feels organic to the story rather than gimmicky. Hepworth uses this perspective to reveal crucial information that would otherwise remain hidden, making it serve both plot and thematic purposes effectively.
How does this book compare to Sally Hepworth’s other works?
The Soulmate is darker and more serious than Hepworth’s previous novels, lacking her trademark dark humor. However, it showcases her most ambitious narrative structure and deepest character development, making it arguably her strongest work despite the tonal shift.
What content warnings should readers be aware of before reading?
The book contains detailed discussions of suicide, mental illness, infidelity, and psychological manipulation. Readers sensitive to these topics should approach with caution, as the subject matter is integral to the plot and cannot be easily avoided.
